Showing posts with label radiation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label radiation. Show all posts

Tuesday, 16 April 2013

Contamination of fish catches in the Irish sea by Depleted Uranium Penetrators


Information  has  been released by the MOD in response to a FOI request asking

"Could you please provide me with Information including reports etc
about the object recovered by fishermen mentioned at para 3, D of
the DUFERC minutes dated 19/10 1999"

In response to this,  the MOD directed me to a reply they made to a similar request


Recovered DU penetrator


The information the MOD provided only relates to the physical characteristics of the recovered round. Of particular note  is the reference made to "black and friable DU oxide" indicating  a significant risk of loose DU contamination.


This DU penetrator was one of over 6000 lying on the seabed of the Irish Sea


"Some 6,907 shells have been fired into the Solway, and, even allowing for misfires and malfunctions, more than 6,000 are presumably now lying in the Solway. Many of us instinctively object to the Solway being used as a radioactive munitions dumping ground by the MOD."

The MOD have not provided any information about the potential doses and intakes of DU to the fishermen who recovered the round or any information about the extent to which the fish etc caught alongside the round were contaminated with DU or whether or not the catch was sold for human consumption.

The recovery of this DU penetrator begs the question how many other similar situations may have occurred, but where the presence of a DU penetrator in the catch was not recognised or reported.

The MOD in not providing information about dose estimates from the recovered DU penetrator seem to have been negligent in their duty of care to the fishermen who recovered the DU penetrator and the public who may have consumed the fish etc caught alongside the DU penetrator. 

Friday, 19 October 2012

DU Firing programme at Eskmeals - As Low As reasonably Practical ?


Reference 1
Looking back to the UK depleted uranium firing programme and in particular the firings carried out Eskmeals on the west Cumbrian coast. It is interesting to consider to what extent these firing complied with the duty to restrict exposures to as low as level as reasonably practical (ALARP).  

The 
IRR99 and the IRR85 requires employers to keep exposure to ionising radiation as low as reasonably practicable. 

VJ Battery at Eskemals in the early years was essentially a traditional open butt with the addition of a roof and extract ventilation from each side of the butt. this allowed the spray back of aerosolised DU and fragements through the open air onto a apron in front of the butt.

To quote from the reports :-



"The penetrator on impacting with the target produced pyrophoric fragments which rapidly disintegrate and. there is a spray back-up the range over an angle of 20 degrees  for a distance of 60 metres."

"Total activity in air measurements taken outside the butt indicate that DU is being released to the environment at levels above the DAC for a period of time after firing. It is not possible to quantify the amounts.".   DAC "Derived Air Concentration" ICRP 30

"The DU dust was found to be well within the respirable size range, dust particles of this size have very long settling times and can remain airborne  for very long periods of time and if allowed to disperse from the butt may travel many hundreds of meters."


This is the  Department of Defense Superbox DU firing facility at Aberdeen Proving Ground Maryland USA. As can be seen the facility offers almost complete containment. It includes a flight tunnel with a drop down door.  The Superbox facility is seen as an example of a facility that reduces exposures to the public and workers outside the facility to a level that is  ALARP



The conclusion is that  that in the early years of the firing programme the MOD failed to meet its legal duty to restrict exposures to as low as level as reasonably practical. It is also interesting to consider that that the VJ Battery at Eskmeals was probably very quick and cheap to build compared to the Superbox facility in the USA. 

It is now also clear that the MOD failed to seek letters of agreement from the Environment Agency for the discharge of DU to atmosphere from VJ Battery at Eskmeals. This was in breach of the MODs' own policies.

Later years of the firing programme at Eskmeals

DRPS Report "Comparison of Kirkcudbright and Eskmeals Environmental Monitoring Data with Generalised Derived Limits for Uranium" June 2002 mentions that a tunnel was added to the face of VJ Butt in order to reduce discharges of DU to the environment. This acknowledged that the original firings at VJ did not comply with the requirement to restrict exposures to as low as level as reasonably practical.

References

1: HSE Reducing risks protecting people 2001

Friday, 12 October 2012

Radiation Protection Technical Advisory Committee (RAPTAC)

In response to a FOI request the MOD has released some of the minutes of the Radiation Protection Technical Advisory Committee (RAPTAC). 

This is the main Committee concerned with ionising radiation protection. The papers provide an insight in the issues of concern to MOD Officials in the late 1970s and early 1980s. 

 It is notable that the MOD have only provided 3 sets of minutes not the 10 requested.. 

 Issues of note include : 


  • Nuclear test veterans 
  • Retention and recruitment of Health Physicists 
  •  Radiation dose limits 
  • Application of the proposed Ionising Radiation Regulations to the MOD 


 Minutes 

1983 2nd meeting 
1980 1st meeting 
1979 2nd meeting 
Covering letterFOI and response 

FOI and response

Thank you for your email of 14 September 2012 requesting the following information: Could you please provide me with the following information:- 

1: Terms of reference of the Radiation Protection Advisory Committee (RAPTAC) referred to in the 12th report of the House of Commons Defence Committee Radiological Protection of Service and Civilian Personnel 
 2: date of the first meeting of RAPTAC 
 3: Agendas of the first 10 meetings 
 4: Minutes of the first 10 meetings 

We are treating your correspondence as a request for information under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. We have now completed an extensive search of archives for the information you requested and we have located the following documents.

RAPTAC 2nd Meeting 1979 – Minutes 
RAPTAC 1st Meeting 1980 – Minutes 
RAPTAC 2nd Meeting 1983 – Agenda
RAPTAC 2nd Meeting 1983 – Minutes 
RAPTAC 1st Meeting 1984 – Agenda 
RAPTAC 2nd Meeting 1984 - Agenda 

We have provided all the information that we could locate for you. These documents have been assessed under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and personal information has been redacted under the Absolute Exemption Section 40.

Wednesday, 26 September 2012

MOD Radiation Protection and Radioactive Waste Committee Papers


In response to a FOI request the MOD have released  the minutes of a number of committees concerned with radiation protection and the management of radioactive waste.

Link to FOI requesting :-

"a; the minutes,
b: agendas
c: Terms of reference

for

a: the Radiation Protection Policy Committee (RPPC)
b: the Radioactive Waste Working Group (RWWG)
c: the Radioactive Waste Information Group (RAWIG),

for the period 1990 to 2000"

The MOD provided the following information

Radioactive Waste Working Group RWWG

Terms of Reference

Minutes

7  January 1999
20 May 1999
9 September 1999
13 January 2000
7 June 20000
19 September 2000

Radiation Protection Policy Committee RPPC

Terms of Reference

a:                    b:

Minutes

17 October 1996
28 January 1998
9 June 1998

Radioactive Waste Information Group RAWIG

Terms of Reference -  not provided

Minutes

13 January 1999
18 May 2000
8 November 2000

Its notable that apart from the agendas these are the only documents provided,  the MOD said that

 " Despite an extensive search of the archives we have been unable to locate a complete set of minutes, agendas and terms of reference for the committees detailed in your request. Some of the files which may have contained the minutes, agendas and terms of reference for the committees have been destroyed."   

 It seems very surprising that the minutes of MOD central committees dealing with issues as significant as radiation safety and the management of radioactive waste and radioactively contaminated land  have been lost or destroyed. 

These remaining documents  provide a snap-shot  of the radiation protection and radioactive waste issues faced by the MOD and show how the MOD was responding. The documents  also provide a good indication of the value of the papers that have been lost.

The more cynical  may be suspect, within the MOD there is a deliberate policy of destroying  files to avoid  answering difficult questions about past activities and dodging liability.  Such a policy appears to have resulted  in  a "corporate lobotomy"  so far as knowledge of  historic activities are concerned. It also results in an inability to learn from history that would help inform decisions concerning current activities and issues.


Failure to ensure the preservation of the minutes of the  central MOD Committee concerned with Radioactive Waste Management for the  period 1975 to 1985.

Saturday, 15 September 2012

A look back at radiation protection in the MOD's nuclear programmes


In 1990  the 12th  report of the  House of Commons Defence Committee was published. Looking at the report today provides a very interesting view of radiation protection and doses to both civilians and service personnel  working in the Defence Nuclear programmes in the late 1980s.

Link to the report.  

The report provides an insight into how the MOD was responding to the Gardner report and also touches on the need to counsel radiation workers about their exposures to radiation.  The report also discusses the no fault compensation scheme .

COMARE advice on the Gardner report

The report  mentions  the Graduate Entry Training scheme for Health Physicists  (GETS). The GET scheme  became a victim of the fragmentation of the defence nuclear sector, especially when AWE  no longer participated.  It was from this point on that the active career management  of MOD Health Physicists took a steep downhill turn. This also reflects the demise of the scientific civil service with the move away from engineering and science grades to a broad banded  grade structure,  which  includes a science and engineering skills framework.


Recruiting and retaining specialist staff

when asked "have there been difficulties in recruiting and retaining specialist staff" Surgeon Captain Harrison replied "I think there always has been, but the Ministry has responded to this by starting up a graduate entry training scheme for health physicists which has been running now some four to five years and this is brining really good first class graduates  into the service".

Over 20 years after the publication of the 12th  report of the  House of Commons Defence Committee ; the retention of specialist staff including health physicists remains  to this day a significant issue and risk to the safety of MOD's  nuclear programme, with little indication of progress in finding a solution.

Links

Counselling Scheme

MOD page on compensation scheme

Radiation Compensation Scheme

Wednesday, 15 August 2012

Radium contamination confirmed at Pulham

In January I said in this blog that RAF/RNAS Pulham  provides a typical  example of a site potentially  contaminated with Radium.

It is now clear from a press report that Radium contamination from past defence activities is present on the site.

It was inquiries made  by Milcon Research and Consulting made to the Local Council that in part prompted the Council to look into the issue of Radium contamination at RAF/RNAS Pulham.


It was also clear the response MOD made to an FOI request that the MOD held no information that would help identify if Radium was present on the site.

It is also clear that there are many more sites such as Pulham where radioactive contaminates and other contaminates are present and may pose a risk to human health and the environment. But that the MOD has long since lost records that would identify such sites.  

Thursday, 28 June 2012

Dalgety Bay the Music Video

An interesting example of how issues involving radioaactivity enter popular culture and have the potential to go viral.

It should noted that its radium not plutonium at Dalgety Bay. But I sure that this detail will be lost for most people watching the video. What will remain is a lasting albeit wrong association of Dalgety Bay with Plutonium.


Wednesday, 2 May 2012

BBC Radio 4 - Face the Facts Radioactive Legacy



Milcon Research and Consulting is  a key contributor to the recently broadcast  BBC programme on  radium contaminated land. The contribution from Milcon Research and Consulting was based on information in the public domain and responses to FOI requests.




BBC reports :-
"A pretty town on the Fife coast remains under threat of an unwelcome distinction. A corner of Dalgety Bay could still become the first place in Britain to be branded as radioactive contaminated land if the Ministry of Defence does not follow through on a plan to deal with radioactive particles washing up on its shore. The MOD's accused of causing the contamination in the first place: aircraft containing potentially hazardous radium were smashed up and buried after the Second World War. The MOD's investigating the scale of the problem and ways it might be put right, but has not promised a full and final clean-up of the bay. That's despite calls for it to do so from the local MP and former Prime Minister, Gordon Brown, and a recent discovery of particles far more radioactive than those previously found. Yet Face the Facts reveals how the MOD has cleaned up other sites deemed far less radioactive; how it's sold off contaminated land for development with radium undetected; how a lack of records means it does not know where similar sites might be and how a confidential government report we've seen from the 1950s warned of the danger of radium dumps being forgotten or, in the case of privately-owned land, deliberately concealed."
Presenter: John Waite
Producer: Jon Douglas

Link to the programme web site

Related Milcon R&C blog posts


Dalgety Bay


Hilsea Lines


Pulham


Chatham 


Failure to provide accurate information in response to FOI requests



Friday, 27 April 2012

Chatham an urban nuclear waste dump and a lasting legacy of the nuclear submarine programme


Background


Chatham Dockyard played a key part in the United Kingdom’s nuclear propulsion programme. Refitting and refueling of nuclear submarines was carried out at Chatham from 1970 until March 1983.  These activities gave rise to radioactive waste which had to be disposed of.  Higher activity wastes were disposed of to BNFL Sellafield in Cumbria. However some of the lower activity wastes were disposed of by local burial within the Dockyard site.  This was done with the agreement of the Regulator HMIP (reference 1) on the assumption the waste contained short lived Cobalt 60 which would decay away over a period of 20 to 30 years. In interesting note that in an answer to a PQ about radioactive waste arrangements at Chatham, there was no mention of the disposal of radioactive waste by burial at Chatham. Hansard (26 Nov 2002: Column 172W)


More about the history of refitting and nuclear work at Chatham Dockyard


Amount of waste buried


Approximately 300 cubic meters of radioactive waste was buried between 1968 and 1986 - reference 2


Risk assessment


Reference 6  to quote the MOD “The risk assessment for the disposal of radioactive waste by burial Chatham - It has not been possible to locate this information, it would have predated the approvals granted by the Department of the Environment in 1980 and has not been located in any of the files recovered”.   This is a significant failure in the MOD’s corporate memory.


Cobalt 60 and Carbon 14 


Cobalt 60 has a short half live of around 6 years, so that after about 24 years the amount of radioactivity will have fallen by approximately 93%. It was on this basis that it was considered safe to dispose of the waste by local burial.


However it came to light that nuclear waste arising from the submarine programme also contains significant amounts of Carbon 14 with a half life of 5,700 years. This issue was picked up by the Governments Independent Advisory Committee on Radioactive Waste Management (RWMAC) in their 2001 report on the Ministry of Defence radioactive waste management practices. Reference 3, 4.  DRPS estimates of carbon 14 in wastes arsing form the naval nuclear prolusion programme can be found at reference 5 paragraphs J and K.


Monitoring


Reference 7:  the attached MOD letter dated 13 October 2008 clearly shows that whilst environmental monitoring for Cobalt 60 was being carried out, it was not for Carbon14. This despite the knowledge dating back to 2001 that Carbon14 may be present.


Burial site


It is notable that the burial site remains MOD property this suggests that  the risks from the buried waste are not insignificant.  The site is walled off by a 3 metre high wall, whilst the site its self has reverted to scrub and woodland.


Google Earth view showing the dump site at Chatham out-lined in red
As can be seen from the image above the burial site the immediate area is undergoing extensive redevelopment including the water-front, a new marina and housing etc.






View of the dump site from Pier Approach Road the dump is behind the wall and appears to be heavily wooded




Conclusion



  • The assumption that Cobalt 60 was only significant radionuclide present in the waste buried at Chatham was mostly likely wrong.
  • The non-availability of a risk assessment or safety case for the burials a Chatham is a serious failing of corporate memory and does little to engender public confidence in the MODs ability to manage the safety of legacy issues over the medium and long term.
  • In the absence of any available safety case, the MOD in conjunction with the Environment Agency needs to publish a revised safety case for the burial site to take account of the presence of Carbon 14 in the waste. The safety case should also demonstrate that the burial meets current standards and regulatory requirements to ensure both environmental and human safety. If this cannot be done to the satisfaction of stakeholders and the Regulators serious consideration must be given to remediation of the site.
  • The situation at Chatham does little to improve public confidence in the Governments policy and the NDAs strategy for managing radioactively waste nationally and the MOD in particular. It remains to be seen how the MOD will respond to issues surrounding the waste dump at Chatham, but if Dalgety Bay is an indicator, the signs for speedy action are not good.



References


1: HMIP agreement to dispose of radioactive waste by burial 
2: MOD letter dated July 1987
3: RWMAC report on the MODs’ radioactive waste management practices 2001 - Carbon14 paragraphs 6.52 to 6.62
4:  MOD response to RWMAC regarding Carbon 14
5: DRPS estimates of Carbon14 in waste streams arising from the Naval Nuclear Propulsion Programme paragraphs J and K
6: Letter dated 7 August 2009 from MOD providing information on burials of radioactive waste at Chatham
7: Letter dated Medway Council dated 29 May 2009 with attached letter from MOD dated 13 October 2008

Sunday, 15 April 2012

Failure to provide accurate information in response to FOI requests



On 18 October 2011 MOD was asked for information about sites contaminated with Radium including those overseas


“Could you please provide the following information a list defence sites in the UK and overseas that have been or might have been contaminated with radium that have been disposed of since 1945. To provide details of radium disposals by on site burial, including amount of radioactivity activity, location and date since 1945.”


The MOD response can be found at the “What do they Know” website



The information provided also fails to identify the site at Hillsea Lines Portsmouth where radium has been disposed of by burial. 


This throws into doubt the accuracy and validity of the information the MOD provides in response to FOI requests.  In particular the unacceptable failings in corporate memory and breaches of statutory duty under the Freedom of Information Act to provide information held by the MOD.

Thursday, 9 February 2012

NAO report Managing change in the Defence workforce impact on skills


National Audit Office report Managing change in the Defence workforce published today points out the Minsitry of Defence is under pressure to make rapid financial savings, is significantly reducing the size of its workforce, by over 54,000 personnel. A report today by the National Audit Office has found that these reductions are happening in advance of the Department’s fully understanding how it will operate with significantly fewer staff.


With regard to skills the report says 


“The significant reduction in headcount creates a risk that current skills gaps will worsen. There is a significant risk that current skills shortages will worsen particularly as at least 16,000 personnel, 30 per cent of the reduction required, is predicted to occur through natural wastage, a process over which the Department has less control than redundancy.”


The recent statement by SEPA on the plans submitted by MOD for the remediation of the beach at Dalgety Bay may indicate that MOD has inadequate specialist skills to manage issues such as radioactive contamination.


"We consider that the plan, as it stands, lacks sufficient detail and have requested more information on a number of areas which include:



  • timescales for implementation of each stage of the plan;
  • more detail relating to the proposed investigation work;
  • investigation plans for Crowhill and Ross Plantation;
  • investigation of remediation options."



It has been previously pointed out that there are significant nuclear safety skills shortages. It will be interesting to see in this year’s report by the Defence Nuclear Environment Safety Board if the situation has changed





Wednesday, 1 February 2012

Ministerial Visit to Dalgety Bay


 It’s interesting to note from a recent PA report on the visit of Defence Minister Andrew Robathan.  He said that “the Ministry of Defence does not deny liability” and went on to say “But I don't think you would expect us to accept liability before we know exactly what the situation is.”


Video report from STV


This is surprising since the MOD has known about the contamination since 1990 and even produced its own risk assessments; surely enough time has passed and information gained to establish the responsibility for the contamination based on reasonable probability.
  

The reference to “industrial sites and ship-breaking” and the “need for further investigations”, seems like an attempt to further muddy the waters and play for even more time.
The reference to “earth movement which of course has of course disturbed a great deal of stuff” suggests that buried radium residues may have been disturbed and brought to the surface with a consequent increase in risk.


It seems that MODs continuing failure to accept that in all probability that the MOD is responsible for the contamination of Dalgety bay is very likely to lead to SEPA designating Dalgety Bay as radioactively contaminated land.


It’s also interesting to see how MODs miss-handling of the radium contamination at Dalgety Bay, and in particular the failure to apologise or accept liability for the contamination may well have played a significant part in shaping people’s views about the options for managing the decommissioned nuclear submarines stored on the Firth of Forth at nearby Rosyth Dockyard. 

Link to press report

Link to press report concerning Devonport and Dalgety Bay

Dalgety Bay provides a classic example of the miss-management of an environmental issue causing reputational damage across all business areas. 


The situation has moved from one concerning essentially scientific and objective decisions to a much more difficult situation primarily driven by ethical and political considerations. This is especially true in the current political environment where the SNP is seeking success in the up-coming referendum on independence.   


31/1/12  (UKPA)  reports


More tests due on bay radioactivity


Further investigations are needed at a beach where radioactive particles were found before anyone should take full responsibility, Defence Minister Andrew Robathan has said.


The Tory MP visited Fife to hand over a draft plan for further action to the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and to see the contaminated area for himself.


It comes after "significant" sources of radiation were discovered at Dalgety Bay on the Firth of Forth coast.


The contamination is thought to stem from residue of radium-coated instrument panels used on military aircraft which were incinerated and land-filled in the area at the end of the Second World War. The area faces the threat of being designated Radioactive Contaminated Land for public protection.


During a short visit to nearby Rosyth, Mr Robathan said the Ministry of Defence does not deny liability and questioned whether a clear-up of the site is needed.


"There was of course a Royal Naval air station here. It closed 53 years ago," he added. "Who knows who's liable. We're not denying liability but I think we need to be quite clear how this contamination has come about.


"For instance, there has been industrial sites. I understand there has been a ship-breaking yard just down the way. There's been earth movement which of course has of course disturbed a great deal of stuff. There's been housing estates built.


"We don't say that we are not in any way willing to help. We are willing to help. But I don't think you would expect us to accept liability before we know exactly what the situation is.


"We are therefore looking at this and we are willing to co-operate with the environment protection agency and others to find exactly what the situation is and then we can determine who is responsible for clearing it up, if there is a need to clear it up."
Last week former prime minister Gordon Brown, MP for Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath, called for urgent action to clean up the site. He has previously urged the MoD to "accept responsibility"







Wednesday, 18 January 2012

Dalgety Bay on-shore Radium Contamination


Recent press reports about Dalgety bay featuring interviews with Gordon Brown speaking about the ”new” discovery of particles of radioactive onshore at Crowhill wood should not ellicit any surprise, it appears that Gordon Brown is playing  catch-up. 


Links to recent press reports




It’s clear from a report that MOD commissioned Enviros to produce in 2009 that the possibility of onshore contamination was an issue. The report  describes on-shore contamination including investigations of domestic properties and gardens built over the former RNAS/RAF Donibristle salvage area in the 1960s.  This and associated reports were released by Defence Estates in response to a FOI request made 2010.


Extract from the Enviros report describing areas surveyed inshore from the beach


Link to full report


“Investigation Works Undertaken


8.  As a result of the data from the first Phase Two LQA and in particular the findings relating to Property D in Zone 2A, a further phase of investigations were undertaken. The site works involved both radiological walkover surveys and intrusive investigation, the areas investigated are summarised below (Zone designation used in original Phase Two LQA are shown in brackets):



  • Dalgety Bay Sailing Club Boat Park (Zone 1): Radiological walkover survey of northern area where access was previously not possible;
  • Property A in Zone 2A and Properties H & I in Zone 4B: Radiological walkover survey and random soil sampling from two properties in Zone 4B.
  • Radiological walkover survey and random soil sampling from one property in Zone 2A which had not allowed access during the original Phase Two LQA.
  • Former Salvage Section (Zone 2A): 1m by 1m gridded radiological walkover surveys and soil sampling in the garden areas of six properties. Where radium-226 and elevated count rates were identified removal of disseminated contamination and point sources was undertaken where possible.
  • Internal Monitoring: Count and dose rate surveys covering accessible areas of the ground floor of six properties on the former Salvage Section and the sailing club house. A similar property outside the impacted area was also surveyed to provide a typical background for the developments which could be used as a comparison.”



Link to full report


Reference: 


DALGETY BAY LAND QUALITY ASSESSMENT PHASE 2B: INTRUSIVE INVESTIGATION AND INTERVENTION LAND QUALITY ASSESSMENT REPORT – FINAL V1 DEFENCE ESTATES, PROJECT NO: 12920, TECHNICAL REPORT, November 2009, by Enviros Consulting.  

Monday, 5 December 2011

MOD policy on contaminated land and alienated sites


In response to a FOI request about how MOD responded to the recommendations contained in the 2000 report by RWMAC    “RWMAC's Advice to Ministers on The Ministry of Defence's Arrangements for Dealing with Radioactively Contaminated Land“. It is clear from the response to action 12 that the MOD has no intention of identifying  what contamination exists on land that it has disposed of prior to the LQA programme such as Dalgety Bay.  


It is also clear from the response to action 12 of the RWMAC report that MOD believes this responsibility lies with Local Authorities.  Local Authorities hold few if any records that would assist them in identifying contamination on former MOD sites let alone the financial resources to support such activity.  


I believe it is important for the safety of the environment and the public, that risks from defence related pollutants are identified and if necessary remediated.  Examples of such pollutants are :-
  • radioactive substances such as  radium, 
  • chemical weapon residues such as mustard gas, 
  • asbestos, 
  • organic solvents, 
  • explosives and ammunition
  • toxic heavy metals such as mercury, lead and cadmium 
I also believe that it is the MODs’  responsibility to  identify where there is a legacy of pollution from defence activities  and where identified as the polluter, MOD should pay to for any clean up rather that  pushing off the responsibility onto poorly resourced local authorities  and council tax payers and Regulators 


RWMAC ACTION PLAN page 3 


Action 12
“MOD should give thought to the feasibility of compiling information on disposals of land predating the LQA programme, where radioactive contamination might have been involved.”


MOD response 


“The introduction of EPA 1990 Part 2A places the responsibility for inspecting land with the local authority to identify land contamination.”

Friday, 11 November 2011

Dalgety Bay and COMARE

It is interesting to note that Dalgety Bay is included in the current work
programme of the Committee on Medical Effects of Radiation in the Environment;
but in response to a FOI request COMARE said :-

"I can confirm that COMARE has not provided any advice to SEPA or MOD on
Dalgety Bay."

This begs a question as to what is the work is COMARE doing in relation to
Dalgety Bay and for whom?

Tuesday, 18 October 2011

Dalgety Bay - an example of the internet empowering citizens


The recent revelations in the media concerning the radioactive contamination of the beach at Dalgety Bay may just provide the impetus to get something done to finally clear of the beach of contamination and to call the polluter to account.
MIlcon Research and Consulting played a key role in supporting the media through analysis of publically available information particularly documents published by SEPA on their website.
The example of Dalgety Bay demonstrates that public bodies can be now held to account by the empowerment of citizens through the use of the internet.  Websites such as the “What do they Know” facilitate the use of both the FOI and EIR regulations by the citizen and ensure that information provided is publicly available.

Monday, 10 October 2011

Radium contamination of Dalgety Bay in Scotland


Since the discovery of radium contamination on the beach at Dalgety Bay in Scotland in the early 1990s there appears little evidence that the problem has been properly addressed and the source of the contamination removed preventing the re-population of the beach with highly radioactive fragments of radium.  SEPA in their recently published report concluded that :- 


“Work undertaken by Defence Estates has confirmed the typical number, size and
activities of point sources at Dalgety Bay. It has also shown that the beach area
continues to re-populate with high activity point sources once cleared and that it is
estimated that over a year these will number about 100 in total. Thus there remains a
hazard to the public at Dalgety Bay from these point sources, and the total number of
radioactive sources at Dalgety Bay remains unknown.


Based on the results of solubility testing, indicative committed effective doses could
range up to 128 mSv for a 3 month old infant, with the majority of the dose being from radium daughters. However, the 2010 work has indicated that the solubility of these sources may be greater than previously expected (25% rather than up to 15%). Doses could also be greater if the relatively small number of samples subjected for leaching was not representative of the population as a whole. Overall our 2006, 2009 and this 2011 report have shown that several of the sources recovered from Dalgety Bay could give committed effective doses in excess of the relevant value for some age groups, prescribed in the Statutory Guidance issued to SEPA by the Scottish Government for Radioactive Contaminated Land.


Direct measurements of point sources to determine potential skin doses have been
undertaken. The results have been reported separately which indicate that it is unlikely the dose rate from the Dalgety Bay sources could exceed the relevant criteria specified in the guidance issued to SEPA by the Scottish Government for Radioactive Contaminated Land.


The potential committed effective doses from Dalgety Bay point sources remain
significant. The primary pathway of concern is via ingestion and as any potential effects (e.g. cancer) may take many years to be expressed and be unlikely to be easily attributable to an exposure from a visit to Dalgety Bay.


The locations and suitability of the current signage, as an optimal intervention measure, should be reviewed. Given the numbers of people using the beach there is also a need for an ongoing monitoring and recovery programme to reduce the hazard present on the beach. In the longer term, as radium has a half life of 1600 years, a programme of work to determine the primary source of the contamination at Dalgety Bay beach and isolate it from the environment may be the only manner in which the level of contamination can be reduced to a negligible level where no further interventions are needed. Given the potential costs involved of developing any robust risk assessment this approach to isolate the contamination from the environment may be the most cost effective approach to mitigating the contamination in the long term. 


The absence of any programme to isolate the radioactive contamination at source will mean that sources which pose a significant hazard to health will continue to be present on the beach at Dalgety Bay. It is concluded that a programme to identify the primary source or sources is needed to reduce the number and hazard of these sources to the public using the beach at Dalgety Bay. “


A point to note is that a recent Press report indicates that material from the beach has been used in children’s sandpits; I do not believe that the risk assessments took account of this possibility.


The Committee on the Medical Effects of Radiation (COMARE) has been tasked to provide advice on the health effects of radium exposure at Dalgety Bay, but has yet to publish its findings.


“Dalgety Bay
The appearance of radium particles at Dalgety Bay first came on the committee’s work programme back in 1990. The discovery of much smaller particles recently has seen this item reappear for further consideration. A site visit by members of the Dounreay Working Group was carried out on 13th May 2008. The committee is continuing to liaise with the MoD and SEPA on this matter. The committee will also be kept aware of other similar contaminated sites as and when issues arise.”


Background information about the historic use of radium by the Ministry of Defence and the problems this created with regard to contaminated land can be found in a report by RWMAC dating back to 2000.


Most recent Press articles as of October 2011
I find it most surprising that after 20 years the beach still  remains contaminated and a significant risk to those who use it; that SEPA, has so far failed to make the “polluter pay”  to clean this contamination up and make the beach safe for unrestricted use. The present publicity relates to the beach little has been said about the potential contamination inshore from the beach.

In response to the press reports the MoD insisted that it took safety very seriously. “We have yet to see the latest findings from SEPA,” said a ministry spokeswoman. “Should significant risks present themselves then SEPA  has the necessary statutory powers to address these.”


This shows how the MOD is doing its best to wash its' hands of this issue and leaving it to others to clean up, so much for MOD saying it takes safety seriously